Join for FREE | Take the Tour Lost Password?
Shop deviantART for the
holidays and save BIG!
Click here! :holly:
[x]

deviantART

:omfg:
 


We've been together too long,
our talk gone woollen
as that of sweaters in closet
for the summer. Our dust
has exchanged bodies;
our smell uniform,
and so moth-like,
it attempts congruency
with wood.

Yesterday I found money
on the kitchen table,
just some loose change
with worn-out faces
as if to suggest the end
of distinct lines, things
you can touch and recognise.

I suppose you're right
about the glasses. I'll see
the optometrist tomorrow.
Meanwhile, here's a bag
with your things. Come
for the rest tomorrow,
although I don't know how
you'll get it off me, all this lint.
:iconlovetodeviate:

Author's Comments

NaPo 11

I apologise to anyone who read this inadvertently.

Critiques


:iconmsklystron:
Overall the feeling expressed hasn't been overdone or done in this way. Your poem describes such a subtle feeling: being distanced by 'lint' and and yet being made similar because of it, while having somehow never managed to penetrate deeper into one another's being. And that's the problem the narrator faces. Her solution, before she and her mate become worn from the outside like the coins she finds is to hand him a bag already packed with his things.

I don't know if this was your intention, but I felt that she'd recited this speech pretty much as she'd planned until the third stanza. He must have interjected about the glasses. But she wasn't thrown off by this and hands him the bag. The narrator's resignation really comes through from start to finish. She seemed very brave to me.

There are a couple of minor wording/ punctuation issues, which others can probably address better than I can. I seem to want the word 'the' between 'in' and 'closet'.

"you can touch and recognize" appears to express the idea of being able to know something by the sense of touch even in the dark. If so, perhaps the word 'and' could be changed to 'to'.

I don't mind 'meanwhile' in the third stanza. It hints at the possibility of things changing after the glasses, not because things may change (if she buys the eyeglasses, she will only see the dulled surfaces more clearly), but rather because the narrator might be in the habit of stifling (as by wool or lint) much of what she says to her mate. This also adds to the sharp contrast between mundane things like eye appointments and asking a mate to leave.

I like the ending very much. "All this lint", seems to have been said to herself or under her breath. It nicely conveys the idea of all the things that can't be packed up and taken away and how lint clings, if only to the surface.

I have to say, your subtle intelligence permeates this poem. It was a pleasure to read.
The Artist thought this was FAIR
5 out of 5 deviants thought this was fair.

:iconmattiello:
Aye, but doesn't the wool protect one from the rain, chill, and heat? At times, I think that knowing someone well enough to be sure that you can talk to that person about anything over and over again, knowing that the other will be interested in whatever it is you want to do, and/or knowing that the other will come to terms or a comprise is something many people in relationships strive for. Yes, a constant supply of this would become annoying or tedious, but that is what girl's night/guy's night out, little vacations with friends/family, reading a book, etc is for. They'll add a little spice to life and conversation with the probability of adding "distinct lines" as well.


Sorry. I got into this way too much.

The first stanza has much more of a poetic touch to it than the other two. The 2nd and 3rd stanza are more prosaic than anything else. Though I like the idea of using worn-out money as a metaphor in the 2nd stanza to support your "woolen" claim, I believe you shouldn't stop there. Show us - the readers - more instances that have lead you to your conclusion. Your technique and vision suffered because of your lack of fluidity between the stanzas and your lack of supporting your overall claim.

If I were you, I'd change the first stanza to prosaic but keep the modernistic ideals, of course, unless you want to upset Ezra Pound. ;) Then add more stanzas to support your claim, thereby lengthening your piece, adding fluidity, and entertaining your readers.

So far, I like your metaphors and overall idea. Though I don't necessarily agree with your idea, I still believe that is a wonderful idea to write about nonetheless.

I hope this isn't too harsh, dear, I honestly like it. Hence the four stars for impact. Just take my critique into consideration if you feel up to it.

:heart: & :rose:

-Joe-

P.S. I said idea and claim too much, didn't I? :no: I didn't have my coffee yet, so perhaps you can excuse me? :D
The Artist thought this was FAIR
10 out of 11 deviants thought this was fair.

Thank you for your Critique

You are not logged in.

Comments


love 0 0 joy 0 0 wow 0 0 mad 0 0 sad 0 0 fear 0 0 neutral 0 0
:icontwobefore-sunrise:
I read it inadvertantly, yet some how fataly, if that makes sense. When I read it at first, it felt a little awkward (probably because I have been writing a lot of rhyming poetry lately so I'm used to structure), but on the second read, I think any awkwardness that isn't created by my OCD is probably fitting for the subject. I really like that it reads smoothly, despite the first verse's obvious poetic vocabulary. By the last stanza it seems bereft, but understandably so.

Only a few things I would consider revising:

'with worn-out faces
as if to suggest the end'

I would find some way to remove the 'as if to' and maybe replace it or just take it out all together.

'the optometrist tomorrow.
Meanwhile, here's a bag
with your things.'

same thing with the 'meanwhile', it's not really needed.

I really like this poem, and thats why I think only four words need to be revised. hope you're well, aditi! xxxx ash
:iconleoraigarath:
The first stanza is mesmerizing, the metaphor and build up, the imagery - it is just... perfect. The second stanza felt a little lingering to me, because the imagery of the first stanza hit me so hard, and the composition of it was so good, the second stanza seemed not to compare. then it hit me that the first stanza is much more emotional, while the second stanza is more rational. The rationality of it, the thoughts behind the things, the lingering effect of thinking-process, takes the edge off things, but adds another dimension to the piece.

The third stanza, although conceptually is beautiful, is still the weakest for me. Just because I feel that you can write it better, stronger, and more puncturing. It feels to me that you didn't get that feel as out as it should, for example - there's a hint of insecurity to it, but I feel that it's not there yet. Not felt enough. This is a beautiful poem nonetheless, and touched me a lot. :+fav:

--
Some days I write those words, others they write me.
:iconjamberry-song:
I think some of the imagery that was intended to sound poignant just comes off sounding silly. Also, some of the metaphors may have been drawn out too far. The first few lines of the poem, for instance. However, this may not be too much of a problem, especially there, because it echoes the sentiment, "We've been together too long". The transitions between stanzas are quite choppy; is there a way you can tie them more together? They seem like snippets from completely different conversations, like listening to a phone conversation and trying to figure out what's going on from the one side you can hear without knowing anything about the other. I do think that this is a problem, because the content is so "sticky"---lint clinging, dust, wool. Perhaps if you pulled the first line from each stanza up to the stanza before it, that would be a quick fix and would be more in tune with the content.

--
dA is for the literary arts, too.
:iconiampoetry:
That first stanza could stand alone!

--
Poetry is truly boundless. It is my passion, I am the canvas.
--
my poetry, lemon
both bitter and tart
you decide the taste of my art

©iampoetry
:iconlovetodeviate:
It probably should. Thanks for reading.

--
Blottingpaper -- my blog | Mimesis -- an international journal of poetry, artwork and opinion
:iconlovetodeviate:
Thanks for reading, Ashley.

--
Blottingpaper -- my blog | Mimesis -- an international journal of poetry, artwork and opinion
:iconlovetodeviate:
Thanks for reading, Omri.

--
Blottingpaper -- my blog | Mimesis -- an international journal of poetry, artwork and opinion
:iconlovetodeviate:
Thanks for reading.

--
Blottingpaper -- my blog | Mimesis -- an international journal of poetry, artwork and opinion
:iconthefavoritesproject:
Your poem has been featured! [link]

Details

April 12
836 bytes

Statistics

14
19 [who?]
820 (1 today)
9 (0 today)

Site Map